I stopped in at the grand opening of Prime Butcher Baker yesterday, the brand new kosher butcher and bakery on 2nd Ave. and 83rd St. brought to you by the owners of Prime Grill, Solo & Prime KO. The place is really nice, clean, well lit and has a wide selection of interesting cuts that you don't usually find at most butchers. With all the interesting variety of meats offered at Prime, it looks like the focus of the store is going to be their dry aged beef, so of course thats what I went with for this little Valentine's day dinner for me and my wife.
I noticed a "filet mignon" in the butcher case, which I found odd considering the filet is an inherently unkosher cut as it comes from the tenderloin - located in the hindquarter of the cow. All cuts from this region are deemed unkosher by Jewish dietary law. The butcher attempted to create a kosher version of the filet by cutting out the "eye" from the ribeye in order to mimic the shape and texture of the tenderloin and then dry aging it. It's a bit expensive, but it was really flavorful and tender.
I pretty much knew immediately that I was going to sear off the beef and finish it in the oven, but I had no idea what I was going to pair it with until I got home and started digging around the fridge. We had some blueberries, so I figured I might as well make a sauce out of it. It was a total experiment, but the sweetness and acidity really complemented the beef nicely and I think it looked really dramatic on the plate. The spinach and polenta were a complete afterthought, but they really rounded out the dish.
